The Ohio workers’ compensation system is meant to protect you by covering all reasonable medical bills and treatment for job-related injuries or illnesses, providing partial wage replacement when you can’t work or need to accept a lower-paying position, and offering disability benefits for lasting impairments. Other benefits include supporting vocational rehabilitation and return-to-work programs and safeguarding you from employer retaliation for filing a claim.
The last benefit is the one that often tends to be overlooked or questioned. In fact, many injured workers in Ohio worry about claiming workers’ comp benefits due to fear of being fired, unaware that they’re protected from retaliation.
At Plevin & Gallucci, we’ve spent decades helping injured workers across Ohio with their workers’ compensation claims. While we don’t handle employment retaliation cases ourselves, we’ve seen how often these issues arise alongside workers’ comp claims and can connect you with appropriate legal counsel if necessary.
Understanding Your Rights Under Ohio Law
Ohio Revised Code Section 4123.90 is a law that prohibits employers from retaliating against you for filing, pursuing, or testifying in any proceedings under the Ohio Workers’ Compensation Act. It helps ensure that workers can seek medical treatment and benefits without fear of losing their jobs.
Ohio follows the “at-will employment” doctrine, which normally lets employers fire workers for almost any reason. However, courts have long held that firing someone for pursuing a workers’ compensation claim violates the protections established by § 4123.90. While Ohio recognizes a broader public-policy wrongful-termination doctrine, the Ohio Supreme Court has made clear that in most workers’ compensation retaliation cases, the remedy provided by § 4123.90 is the most common avenue for relief.
These protections apply to all employees covered by the Ohio workers’ compensation system. You don’t need to have been employed for a certain length of time or show any prior pattern of retaliation by your employer. The protection applies as soon as you file a claim.
What Constitutes Illegal Retaliation?
An employer violates Ohio Revised Code § 4123.90 when they discharge you, demote you, refuse to rehire you, or take another punitive employment action against you because you filed, pursued, or expressed an intent to file a workers’ compensation claim. “Punitive action” includes adverse changes to your compensation, job status, or working conditions that meaningfully affect your employment. Examples include:
- Demotion or Reduced Compensation: Your employer moves you from a supervisory role to an entry-level position, cuts your hours so you can’t make ends meet, or reduces your pay without a legitimate business reason. Courts treat these types of employment actions as “punitive” when they negatively impact your job status or income.
- Denial of Promotions or Benefits: Your employer passes you over for a promotion you were in line to receive, denies you a raise that others in your position get, or excludes you from benefits programs. They might also strip away job responsibilities that made your position valuable or exclude you from important meetings and decisions.
- Threats and Intimidation: Your employer makes veiled threats about your job security or explicitly tells you that filing the claim was a mistake. This behavior creates fear and sends the message that exercising your legal rights will cost you your job. While threats alone aren’t enough for a claim under § 4123.90, they can support your case if they result in a discharge, demotion, or other punitive action, or if they help prove retaliatory motive.
- Constructive Discharge: If your employer makes your working conditions so intolerable that a reasonable person would feel forced to quit, Ohio courts may treat your resignation as a retaliatory discharge. Constructive discharge is actionable if it occurs because you pursued workers’ compensation benefits.
It is important to note that not every negative experience at work qualifies as retaliation under § 4123.90. Harassment, hostility, increased scrutiny, or unfair treatment by themselves typically don’t create a retaliation claim unless they result in a demotion, loss of pay, or constructive discharge. But if your employer takes any action that negatively impacts your job status or compensation because you filed a workers’ compensation claim, you may have grounds for a retaliation action under Ohio law. An experienced employment law attorney can help you understand your specific situation.
Proving Retaliation: What You Need to Know
To prove retaliation under Ohio law, you have to establish three things:
- First, you must show that you filed, pursued, or testified in any proceedings related to a workers’ compensation claim.
- Second, you need to demonstrate that your employer took an adverse employment action such as discharge, demotion, or refusal to rehire.
- Third, you must show a causal connection between your protected activity and the adverse action by demonstrating that your workers’ compensation claim motivated your employer’s decision.
An employment law attorney can help you do this. Here are some key steps:
- Document Everything: Save emails, texts, and written communications from your employer from the time of your injury onward. Keep copies of performance reviews and records created before the injury. Note the dates when you reported the injury, filed the claim, and first noticed changes in your employer’s behavior. These details help establish a timeline and can support your retaliation claim.
- Gather Witness Statements: Coworkers who observed your employer’s behavior can testify about how management treated you before and after your claim. They can also confirm that your employer applied different standards to you than to other employees. Their observations can provide objective evidence that supports your version of events.
- Establish Timing Patterns: When an employer takes a statutory adverse action (especially termination or demotion) soon after you file your claim, the timing can support an inference of retaliation. While timing alone is not enough to prove a case in Ohio, it becomes meaningful when combined with other evidence showing a shift in treatment following your claim.
- Analyze Your Employer’s Explanations: Employers typically offer alternative reasons for their decisions, such as performance issues or policy violations. Examine these explanations carefully. Inconsistencies, shifting justifications, or reasons that don’t align with how the employer treated others in similar situations may indicate that the stated reasons are pretext and that retaliation was the true motive.
- Look for Policy Enforcement Changes: If your employer suddenly enforces rules they previously ignored, or applies standards to you that they don’t apply to others, it can suggest a retaliatory motive, especially if it leads to a discharge, demotion, pay cut, or other punitive action.
What to Do If You Experience Retaliation for Filing a Workers’ Comp Claim
The moment you notice changes in how your employer treats you after filing a workers’ compensation claim, you need to start protecting yourself.
- Report to Human Resources: Put your complaint in writing and send it to your HR department or a supervisor above the person retaliating against you. Explain what happened, when it happened, and why you believe it’s connected to your workers’ comp claim. Keep a copy of everything you submit. Your employer’s response (or lack of response) becomes part of your evidence.
- File a Retaliation Notice With Your Employer: Under Ohio Revised Code § 4123.90, you must provide your employer with a written notice of the claimed violation within 90 days of the adverse action (such as termination). An experienced lawyer can help you prepare this notice, which is required before you can file a lawsuit in court.
- Consider Filing a Lawsuit in the Court of Common Pleas: If your employer fires you because of your workers’ compensation claim, you may bring a civil action against them. The remedies in Ohio are limited by statute: you may seek reinstatement, back pay, and attorney’s fees, but emotional distress damages and punitive damages are not available for workers’ compensation retaliation.
Can Your Employer Fire You While You’re on Workers’ Comp Leave?
Your employer can’t fire you because you filed a workers’ compensation claim or took workers’ comp leave. However, Ohio law does not guarantee job protection just because you’re off work for an injury. Your employer may still terminate you for legitimate reasons unrelated to your claim, such as company-wide layoffs, long-standing performance issues, or neutral attendance policies applied consistently to all employees.
If you are fired during your workers’ comp leave, look closely at the timing and the reasons your employer gives. Sudden rule enforcement, shifting explanations, or weak justifications may indicate that the real motive was retaliation for pursuing your workers’ compensation benefits.
What if You Were an Independent Contractor?
Generally speaking, independent contractors aren’t eligible to file workers’ compensation claims in Ohio, which means the retaliation protections in R.C. 4123.90 don’t apply to them. However, many workers classified as “independent contractors” are actually employees under Ohio law. Employers sometimes misclassify their workforce to avoid paying workers’ comp premiums, payroll taxes, and other benefits.
Ohio looks at the actual nature of the working relationship, not the job title, and considers factors like who controls the work, who provides tools, and whether the worker can truly operate independently. If you believe you were misclassified, an employment attorney can evaluate your job duties and level of control to determine whether you should legally be considered an employee and therefore entitled to workers’ compensation benefits and retaliation protection.
Speak With an Experienced Attorney Today
Ohio law gives you strong protections when you file a workers’ compensation claim. Your employer can’t fire you, demote you, or punish you simply because you exercised your legal right to seek wage and medical benefits for a work-related injury. These protections exist because the state recognizes that injured workers need access to medical care and wage replacement without risking their jobs. Don’t let fear stop you from filing a legitimate claim.
At Plevin & Gallucci, we help injured Ohioans pursue the workers’ comp benefits they’ve earned. If you believe your employer has punished you for filing a claim, we can help connect you with experienced employment law attorneys who handle retaliation cases. To get started, call us today at 1 (855) 4-PLEVIN or send us a message online.
Related:
